Well, that escalated quickly.
I’m still digesting the book, and the prudent thing to do is
to wait a day or so before doing this, but I’ve never been a very prudent
person (I’m pursuing an MFA in Popular Fiction forchrissakes!). So here goes…
Reading Psycho
after knowing the big twist was actually fun from an analytical point of view.
From the first few pages when we meet Mrs. Bates, I could identify some of the
techniques Bloch used to present Norma Bates as a living person without hinting
that she’s really dead. In that first scene, we see that Norman doesn’t look at
or touch his mother. She’s there, in the peripherals, berating him over his
choice of reading materials and terminal bachelorhood. She never comes around
to talk to him face on, and he even mentions that he wants to ignore her as if
she weren’t actually there. What’s fun, is that in those early pages we not
only meet Norman Bates, but also see Norma Bates as if she’s a real, living
person to us as much as she is to him.
There are other instances throughout the book that also
work, such as when he sees her after waking from one of his fugue states. He
sees her as a waking-dream, leading the reader into believing she’s actually
present. It’s pretty brilliant. The first 50 pages was a blast to read and
dissect, even if I knew what was coming.
And then things escalated. And not in a good way. By
escalate I mean spiraled into a clunky narrative of one-dimensional characters,
unbelievable plot points and haphazard mechanics . But, before I get into all
of the bad, I want to point out something great about Bloch’s writing: It’s as
easily digestible today as it was nearly 60 years ago when he wrote this book.
For the most part, the language he used and the dialogue from the characters is
rarely dated. Unlike Richard Matheson, Bloch didn’t use wide brush strokes, but
rather pointed, acute writing that may very well be found in novels written
this decade. Of course, it wasn’t without exception, but even those were rare
moments that usually focused around the technology of the time.
Maybe it’s that time that led us to the biggest plot hole:
why were the police never called? The thin reasoning that the company wanted to
save embarrassment for both Mary Crane and the Lowery firm didn’t make sense to
me. Maybe it was different back then, but I would still think that a $40,000
theft and a missing girl would garner some sort of police response. It’s that
sort of slipshod reasoning that made me roll my eyes more than once. I can’t
really nit-pick Lila Crane’s motives because this was written in the 50s, but
her constant dependence on the men in the book made me squirm. There was never
any chance she could save her sister, but the book would have only been a
hundred pages long if she would have gone to the police when she wanted to.
And let’s face it, we wouldn’t have lost much if that
happened. The first fifty pages were the strongest of the book, and the 150
that followed did little to advance Norman’s story-line. The eventual discovery
of his multiple personalities was delivered in a clinical rundown from a
character that probably should have died in the hotel office, but for some
reason Bloch spared him. I could see this book ending with Lila making a visit
to the State Hospital and talking to the psychiatrist herself (that would help
her character arc as a near-helpless woman to somebody who takes control of the
situation and her life. Instead she leaves it all in the hands of the man that
made the whole ordeal stretch out a week or more longer than it needed to.
Anyway, I’d talk about the climax, but there wasn’t one.
Because, once again, the guy who probably should have died shows up in the nick
of time and has the easiest save of any hero I’ve ever seen or read.
Even with all the negative things I’ve written about, the
pace and brevity of the book made it a decent read, one that can be done on a
lazy morning while sipping coffee (and that’s just how I read it).
Chad,
ReplyDeleteGood points that I will now proceed to argue with. Haha. First of all I totally agree about the first 50 or so pages. I just commented on Vanessa's blog that because I did know the secret, I was able to see the techniques Bloch used and how successful they were. And yes, he is easy to read now as he was when the book came out.
This leads me right into the disagreements. As much as a women's libber I am, I have to say, I bought Lily's actions as a product of her time. Men knew better and a "smart women" listened to what the men said. So I bought that.
As for not wanting to embarrass anyone, again, I think its a product of the times. Polite society avoided embarrassment especially these sorts of things. Parents sent pregnant teens away to live with Aunts or Cousins until the baby was had and given away. Some story about the peace corps or a sick relative was given as an excuse for their absence--all to avoid embarrassment. Would you give your hard earned money to a company that had lost 40,000 when one of their own employees stole it?
I do appreciate your modern man sentimentality though.
Joe-la
Chad, you're right about being "in on the joke" allowed us to read Psycho with a more critical eye. Bloch did a good job of misleading us whenever Norma Bates was talking.
ReplyDeleteI agree it was odd they never called the cops on her, but like Joe-La said, nobody wants to deal with a company that can't keep its own employees from stealing from it.
I also really enjoyed looking for all the ways Bloch fools us into thinking that Mrs. Bates is still alive. This story has become so embedded in our pop culture, that even the first time I watched Psycho as a kid, I knew Mrs. Bates was dead. I wonder what it would have been like to discover that surprise for the first time. It's probably a big part of the reason the book was turned into a movie.
ReplyDeleteThe first 50 pages were the strongest by far. It makes me wonder if Bloch added much of the middle filler waiting scenes for length. I'm with Joe-la on the women's role in this and the embarrassment motives. It fits the time period. Obviously, we couldn't get away with neglecting to contact police about a missing person and missing money now. In fact, I think our modern thinking would be that something shady happened to Mary while she was on her way to the bank rather than assuming she stole the money and try to find her to save everyone's reputation.
ReplyDeleteChad,
ReplyDeleteI can't help but agree with you about that ending. After all the build-up of how twisted Norma is supposed to be and how desperately Norman wants to protect her, the sheriff just happening to show up at the right moment despite his constant reluctance throughout the story to even talk to Norman felt way to convenient.
And I couldn't help but feel like the actual scene where Norman is finally taken down was anti-climatic. I was expecting more suspense with Lila hiding from Bates. But I guess in a way it might be more realistic. Also the explanation for waht is wrong with Norman felt too much like there was more telling. I think Bloch could have played more with how that information was revealed in the end. But I did enjoy reading the book as well.
Chad,
ReplyDeleteYou commend Bloch for disguising Norma's presence, and I agree that it was done quite well. As someone who was still unfamiliar with the whole story, I was trying to figure out the circumstances of the Bates home for at least a third of the novel. You also note the easily digestible writing style that feels almost modern, and I agree. It was a nice surprise, as I was prepared for something that dragged a bit more, and your description of pointed, acute writing is completely accurate.
Although I understand your perspective, I have to disagree somewhat with your point on Lila. You seem to imply that she is a helpless female character, but I found it to be a point made on Bloch's part on how people during that time tended to look the other way, in hopes that the situation would just disappear. I also saw him commenting on how society viewed women as overreacting on their emotions (unfortunately still a bit true today). However, I think this point may have been made more apparent if Lila was able to save herself from being chased by Norman. And in relation to that, you make an excellent point on Sam having the easiest hero save ever.
Klarisa